Skip to content
Electrical Tips

Home Electric Generators: Choosing Between Gas and Natural Gas Options

Updated

Power outages don't have to leave you in the dark. Compare portable and standby generators, fuel options, and sizing for your home.

Written by the licensed electricians at First Choice ElectricMO License #2025001688

Need this done? Whole-Home Generator Installation in St. Louis & St. CharlesSee pricing and book →

Home Generators: Gas vs. Natural Gas Options

Power outages happen. Whether from storms, grid failures, or equipment problems, losing electricity is more than inconvenient. It can be dangerous. Understanding your generator options helps you choose the right backup power solution.

Whole-Home Generator Installation for St. Charles & St. Louis County homes

Free on-site estimate, flat price before any work starts.

Generator Types for Homes

Portable Generators

What they are: Wheeled units that run on gasoline, stored until needed.

Power output: 3,000-12,000+ watts

Advantages:

  • Lower purchase cost
  • Can be used for camping, job sites
  • No permanent installation
  • Easy to maintain

Disadvantages:

  • Manual startup and connection
  • Must store and manage fuel
  • Cannot run during carbon monoxide concerns (inside garage)
  • Limited runtime on one tank
  • May not power whole house

Best for: Occasional outages, essential circuit backup, budget-conscious homeowners.

Inverter Generators

What they are: Portable generators with cleaner power output, suitable for sensitive electronics.

Power output: 1,000-7,000+ watts

Advantages:

  • Clean sine wave power (safe for electronics)
  • Quieter operation
  • More fuel efficient
  • Compact size

Disadvantages:

  • Higher cost than conventional portables
  • Less power per dollar
  • Still require manual operation

Best for: RVing, camping, or supplemental home power for electronics.

Standby Generators

What they are: Permanently installed units that start automatically during outages.

Power output: 7,500-50,000+ watts (whole-house capable)

Advantages:

  • Automatic operation (no manual startup)
  • Powers entire home seamlessly
  • Runs on natural gas or propane (no fuel storage)
  • Longer runtime (unlimited with natural gas)
  • Higher resale value for home

Disadvantages:

  • Higher purchase and installation cost
  • Requires professional installation
  • Needs periodic maintenance
  • Permanent outdoor installation

Best for: Frequent outages, medical equipment needs, home office dependency, comfort priority.

Fuel Comparisons

Gasoline

Pros:

  • Readily available
  • Works with portable generators
  • High energy density

Cons:

  • Must be stored safely (fire hazard)
  • Goes stale in 3-6 months
  • Not practical for long outages
  • Fuel station may be closed during outages

Natural Gas

Pros:

  • Unlimited supply (if line intact)
  • No fuel storage or handling
  • Cleaner burning
  • Always "fresh": doesn't degrade

Cons:

  • Requires existing natural gas service
  • Gas line installation adds cost
  • Lower energy density than gasoline
  • Gas service may be disrupted (rare)

Propane (LP)

Pros:

  • Longer shelf life than gasoline
  • Available for homes without natural gas
  • Stored onsite in tanks
  • Works with standby or dual-fuel generators

Cons:

  • Tank must be filled (planning required)
  • Finite supply during outage
  • Takes up yard space
  • Higher fuel cost than natural gas

Sizing Your Generator

What You Need to Power

ItemApproximate Watts
Refrigerator600-800 (running), 2000 (starting)
Sump pump800-1500
Furnace blower500-2000
Well pump1000-4000
Window AC1000-1500
Central AC3000-5000
Lights (LED)10-20 each
Phone/laptop charging50-100

Key consideration: Motor loads (pumps, AC) need extra power for startup.

Generator Sizing

ScenarioMinimum Generator Size
Essentials only (fridge, lights, phone)3,000-5,000W
Essentials + sump pump + furnace5,000-7,500W
Most circuits except AC/range10,000-15,000W
Whole house including AC20,000-30,000W+

Electrical Requirements

For Portable Generators

Inlet box installation:

  • Outdoor power inlet near generator location
  • Connects to transfer switch inside
  • Allows safe, code-compliant connection

Transfer switch:

  • Prevents backfeeding power to utility lines (dangerous)
  • May be manual or automatic
  • Selects which circuits receive generator power

Never: Run generator power through extension cords plugged into outlets (fire hazard, backfeed hazard).

For Standby Generators

Automatic transfer switch (ATS):

  • Detects power loss
  • Signals generator to start
  • Transfers home to generator power
  • Returns to utility when power restores

Electrical connections:

  • Dedicated circuit for generator controls
  • Connection to transfer switch
  • May require panel upgrade for larger units

Natural gas connection:

  • Dedicated gas line sized for generator
  • Shutoff valve at generator
  • Performed by licensed gas fitter

Installation Considerations

Placement Requirements

Standby generators need:

  • Clearance from windows and doors (exhaust concerns)
  • Distance from property lines (code varies)
  • Level concrete pad or mounting surface
  • Access for maintenance
  • Protection from flooding

Code requirements: Setbacks from openings typically 5+ feet; check local codes.

Permit Requirements

Usually required for:

  • Standby generator installation
  • Transfer switch installation
  • Gas line work
  • Electrical panel modifications

Maintenance Needs

Portable Generators

  • Change oil after first 20-30 hours, then every 100 hours
  • Check air filter regularly
  • Run monthly for 15-30 minutes
  • Use fresh fuel or fuel stabilizer
  • Store properly when not in use

Standby Generators

  • Weekly automatic test runs
  • Annual professional inspection
  • Oil and filter changes per schedule
  • Battery replacement every 2-4 years
  • Air filter and spark plug service

Costs

Generator TypeEquipment CostInstallation Cost
Portable (5-7kW)$800-$2,000$300-$800 (inlet + switch)
Inverter (3-5kW)$1,000-$3,000$300-$800 (inlet + switch)
Standby (10-15kW)$3,000-$6,000$2,000-$5,000
Standby (20-30kW)$5,000-$12,000$3,000-$7,000

Note: Gas line installation adds $500-$2,000+ if needed.

Making Your Decision

Consider:

  • How often do you lose power?
  • How long do outages typically last?
  • What must stay powered (medical, sump pump, comfort)?
  • Is natural gas available?
  • What's your budget for purchase and installation?
  • Do you want automation or manual operation?

Contact us for generator installation or transfer switch services.

Tags:

#Advancements in Generator Technology#Eco-Friendly Power Generators#Emergency Power Solutions#Fuel-Efficient Generators#Gas-Powered Generators#Generator Safety and Installation#Home Electric Generators#Home Generator Maintenance#Natural Gas Generators#Residential Backup Power

Whole-Home Generator Installation for St. Charles & St. Louis County homes

Free on-site estimate, flat price before any work starts.

Get new posts by email

One short email when we publish. No spam, unsubscribe any time.